Avernum 4 Observations
Pages
| Author | Topic: Avernum 4 Observations |
|---|---|
|
Warrior
Member # 10234
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 07:57
Profile
So I've been playing some Avernum 4 and reading about it here and have some feedback on what I like and dislike (not much on the latter). I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts, especially if you've been testing Avernum 5. For perspective, I owned Exile: Escape from the Pit, and bought/played through some of both of Nethergate: Res. and Blades of Avernum. Played through some of the other demos, and a GeneforgeIV CD is in the mail! Likes: Graphics - smoother graphic movement, battle animation, better textures and shading overall. I put extra weight on this aspect as it has improved the gameplay feel for me more than anything else. The dislikes I have (below) are small concerns since I like the new look so much. User Interface - Aside from picking up items, everything seems to work much slicker and more intuitively. I like the Journal icon on the sidebar, for instance, more than the list of quests in the character screen in N:R. Ambient sound effects: They might not have changed much, but I still like the various background effects. (I haven't heard that annoying "crying boy at the market" yet!) Job Board: Very cool idea. Get quests in one location, too rather than running around. Area descriptions: As usual, the Spiderweb Soft. descriptions of areas and rooms add much to the feel of the game. Perhaps my favorite aspect of the SS games. For some reason the Avernum IV conversations and descriptions seem better than ever. Dislikes: Less PC Character Models - I miss the cool looking female Slith wizard and additional human faces / bodies from Blades of Avernum. There is no tough-guy looking human fighter anymore, just the goatee'd dude who looks like a strong puff of wind could knock him over (yes, I know he's "wiry" - ha) User interface - something about picking things up and/or clicking on items to pick up or identify seems to include an extra step compared to BoA and N:R. A lot of dragging and dropping into inventory. Maybe I've yet to figure out the trick. Load Game: Double clicking load game doesn't load my games. It's a click, move, click checkmark extra step. Graphics: Characters appear a bit too..."upright", especially when moving. I'd like to see more crouching, springing, striding and battle-ready stances. Neutral: Sounds - Just OK. Icons - seem a bit dated compared to the rest of the engine, perhaps just because I've seen the same icons in N:R and BoA. Maybe its that the leather armor icon, for instance, doesn't seem to share the same depth of shading that the Geneforge engine provides. Overall it looks great, and I'm hyped about Avernum 5. I have to wonder if any of my dislikes were addressed. [ Monday, October 01, 2007 07:59: Message edited by: Ming ] Posts: 102 | Registered: Monday, September 3 2007 07:00 |
|
Shock Trooper
Member # 10374
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 08:55
Profile
I've also played Avernum 4 for cuite a bit.I also played Geneforge series and A1-3.My opinion is that A4 has much improved compared to other Avernums.There are a lot things that I liked and few that didn't. Likes: 1)The thing that I liked the most is that it uses Geneforge engine(first Spiderweb game whic I played is A4 followed by G1-4 and then A1-3),I got so used to it that I had trouble to adapt to Avernum engine. 2)I also got used to Geneforge movement (one click where I want to go)that I liked it very much. 3)I to liked new graphicks ,battle animations,and the looks of the game thats different from previous Avernums. 4)I very much liked that if you want to talk to somebody or open a box you just click on it,you dont have to use talk icon or right mouse button to do that(which annoyed me)or if you want to pick up something from the ground you open inventory and drag it where you want. 5)quote: _________________________________________________ originaly writen by Ming: Job Board: Very cool idea. Get quests in one location, too rather than running around _________________________________________________ Agree 100% 6)Descriptions of caves, rooms, people and strange events give the felling to game.Really liked it. Dislikes: 1)There should be more characthers of common people like townspeople, merchants,...not just boring two female and two male characthers, its annoying to me that everyone looks the same. 2)There are a lot of weak boring monsters that attack me on every step.I can't get passed from one town to another without being attacked by bandits, chitraches, rats,...I hope in A5 will be less. 3)There are no boats or elevators.It would have been much better with them.Glad they are back! Overall very good.I would rate it 9.7 Its my favourite Spiderweb game. Can't wait till Avernum 5 will be out for windows. -------------------- If you listen to LakiRA@ all will go well! Posts: 263 | Registered: Sunday, September 9 2007 07:00 |
|
Electric Sheep One
Member # 3431
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 09:21
Profile
Beta testers aren't supposed to reveal details about the game before release. But I'm pretty sure Jeff has already stated here somewhere that there will be a few more player character models in A5. I'm pretty sure that A4, like the Geneforge games, lets you pick things up by typing the letter of the little 'box' in which each object shows up, after you type 'g' for 'get' stuff. So 'g' then 'a' will move the first visible item from the ground or container into the inventory of the active character. The graphical complaints: yeah. Jeff gradually upgrades his graphics, adding or improving a few things every game. So whatever you don't like will probably get improved at some point, but not everything you want may get done by A5. G6 will have further improvements. I really liked A4 too, since it was my first real exposure to Avernum. I came to Spiderweb for Geneforge 1, and found it hard to get into the more primitive-looking Avernum games. A lot of the people who had already played the Exile series, then their remakes as Avernum, found the plot of A4 too familiar and straightforward. -------------------- We're not doing cool. We're doing pretty. Posts: 3335 | Registered: Thursday, September 4 2003 07:00 |
|
Warrior
Member # 10234
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 09:51
Profile
quote:Wow, that is certainly my favorite aspect, and I forgot about it completely. I often click as far away as possible and grab for a sip of coffee while they move. quote:Oops, on the beta thing. Good to hear about more player char. models though! And even if he doubles up the portraits on one model and just changes the color scheme I won't complain. Posts: 102 | Registered: Monday, September 3 2007 07:00 |
|
Law Bringer
Member # 6785
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 12:44
Profile
A4 and A5 have two groups of quests. The job board which is based on the dispatcher of A3/E3 idea and there are quests that you get from talking to people. It's easy to miss them if you take the wrong dialog branch or find that you got one and didn't notice it while playing. Jeff did do what he said about adding more character graphics especially for the nonhumans. Still it would be nice to have a few more. There's always A6. Posts: 4643 | Registered: Friday, February 10 2006 08:00 |
|
Warrior
Member # 10234
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 13:17
Profile
quote:I liked that the job board can be empty, but then something (like where you've been on the map?) triggers more postings to it. quote:It never occurred to me that it was probably pretty lame to have a full Slith party with two character portraits. Those Slith, they all look alike 'ya know. ;) I guess Jeff's idea was that he needed a single portrait to match with a single model and have each one be unique, but really, a different colored loincloth and different portrait would be fine for me. Same goes for the Humans. Bring back all of the old portraits Jeff! :D [ Monday, October 01, 2007 13:20: Message edited by: Ming ] Posts: 102 | Registered: Monday, September 3 2007 07:00 |
|
Board Administrator
Member # 1
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 14:57
Profile
Homepage
Avernum 5 has far fewer trivial monsters, both in the wild and in dungeons. There are 6 new character graphics. 2 human, 2 nephil, 2 slith. - Jeff Vogel -------------------- Official Board Admin spidweb@spiderwebsoftware.com Posts: 960 | Registered: Tuesday, September 18 2001 07:00 |
|
Canned
Member # 8014
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 15:07
Profile
quote:That is good to hear (or...read). Whey did you remove some (a lot) of the graphics in the first place? [ Monday, October 01, 2007 15:11: Message edited by: Iffy will bring you warm fuzziness. ] -------------------- Muffins n' Hell|Muffins n' Hell: The Muffins Are Back Again I have an addiction to Spiderweb games. I like this image FYI, Iffy is short for Infernal Flamming Muffin. Posts: 1799 | Registered: Sunday, February 4 2007 08:00 |
|
Warrior
Member # 10234
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 18:32
Profile
quote:Great news, Jeff. Another reason why I love this board is the chance to read feedback from the programmer himself. Now I'll just have to keep myself busy with the three games I bought until early 2008...! Posts: 102 | Registered: Monday, September 3 2007 07:00 |
|
...b10010b...
Member # 869
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 18:48
Profile
Homepage
quote:Because scaling up the graphics from previous Avernum games would have made them look ugly, that's why. -------------------- The Empire Always Loses: This Time For Sure! Posts: 9973 | Registered: Saturday, March 30 2002 08:00 |
|
Shaper
Member # 247
|
written Monday, October 1 2007 21:22
Profile
Homepage
quote:Thanks tips. -------------------- The Knight Between Posts. Posts: 2395 | Registered: Friday, November 2 2001 08:00 |
|
Lifecrafter
Member # 7557
|
written Tuesday, October 2 2007 11:50
Profile
quote:It shouldn't be to hard to create more character portraits. There are thousands of them for games like NWN and Baldures Gate. And you can edit the character figures in paint if your desperate. Posts: 942 | Registered: Sunday, October 8 2006 07:00 |
|
Warrior
Member # 10234
|
written Tuesday, October 2 2007 16:28
Profile
Well, those were mostly fan-made rips of other artist's work. If you look at the original Baldur's gate, there were about as many as in the Avernum series. Very well painted and beautiful, but the portraits were limited. It's not like Jeff can just go in to the NWN:Vault and steal some portraits for the games he sells. :eek: :P Besides, I'm guessing he wants some sense of consistency in the portraits that look like the work of Phil Foglio. Posts: 102 | Registered: Monday, September 3 2007 07:00 |
|
Apprentice
Member # 10811
|
written Tuesday, October 2 2007 21:53
Profile
I'm having a lot of gameplay issues with A4 so far. Some of these issues are probably just a matter of my having to get used to the new engine, but some of them seem rather more serious than that to me. For example: I find it really hard to distinguish the stuff lying on the ground that you can (and might want to) pick up from the stuff that isn't "really" there but is instead just kind of painted on. In the older engine, you could use the right mouse button or the keyboard to see what items were in a room and available for manipulation. In this engine, you're just somehow supposed to intuit -- presumably through some mystical sense which I, sadly, was born lacking -- which of these random blobs of pixels represent actual manipulable objects, and which are just there for atmosphere or color or what have you. I have no idea how one is supposed to make this distinction. They all look the same to me, and the situation is not helped by the fact that you need to be standing quite close to something for it to show up as an option when you type 'g.' I'm still struggling my way though the demo, and I have to say that so far, much of my gameplay seems to consist of trying to pick up items that don't really exist (even though they sure look like items!), or finding out on a replay that I'd previously missed an item that was only one square out of my reach when I'd tried to "get" in that location before, etc., etc. It's really not fun. Posts: 6 | Registered: Saturday, September 29 2007 07:00 |
|
Apprentice
Member # 3942
|
written Tuesday, October 2 2007 23:47
Profile
I too really dislike the Avernum 4 engine. I've tried to like it, and I played through the demo when it first came out, but it just fills me with feelings of frustration and loathing. I spend *so* much of my time either scrolling the side of the screen so that I can see my destination. When I played it originally, there was also a huge amount of lag, which would get worse as time went on. That was machine specific, rather than game specific - a friend of mine played it on her computer, and had no difficulties - but my laptop was still relatively recent, and it shouldn't have happened. This doesn't seem to be happening with my new laptop, however. Back to the game - I dislike that items are often hidden by walls, especially important things, such as trapdoors. I really don't like the fact that spells no longer have letters attached to them - yes, I can still press 'a' in order to select the first spell, but it's difficult to know which letter to press when it comes to the later spells. It's also *really* inconvenient that enemies no longer have letters attached to them, as it makes casting spells in battle more tedious because one has to select the enemy with the mouse each time. When characters are bunched up together, it can be a pain to move the mouse into the right position in order to be able to click on the intended enemy. I also really dislike how the new graphics look. I've tried to like this game, and I've tried to like Geneforge, but the engine just makes me angry and frustrated. I would play the other Avernum game for hours upon hours upon hours, but with this I'll play for 10 minutes, get really annoyed, and quit. (I'll still download the demo for A5 when it comes out, though. Yes, I'm an addict.) -------------------- Yes, it is bread we fight for//but we fight for roses, too! Posts: 3 | Registered: Friday, January 30 2004 08:00 |
|
Law Bringer
Member # 6785
|
written Wednesday, October 3 2007 08:44
Profile
Jeff fixed A5 so you can attack and target monster using the keyboard as well as the mouse. For spell casting try using "c" to get a table with all the spells you can cast and then pick the letter. I found that I remembered most of the spell letters for mage and priest casting after a few days of playing. Posts: 4643 | Registered: Friday, February 10 2006 08:00 |
|
Apprentice
Member # 8406
|
written Wednesday, October 3 2007 09:19
Profile
i hate using the mouse in games, unless they're first person shooters. Posts: 47 | Registered: Thursday, March 29 2007 07:00 |
|
Warrior
Member # 10234
|
written Wednesday, October 3 2007 10:16
Profile
quote:Of the things you wrote, this is the only one I agree with. My guess is that the editor Jeff uses is in 2D (like the editor for BoA) so he cannot see how bad this is when he's making the game. I hope that the playtesters for A5 let Jeff know when a trapdoor is "hidden" like that (there's an important one in the very first town of A4, and that' just wrong). There is nothing good or realistic about having the POV hide an object. Venatrix Avia, I also miss the ability to click on an object on the ground to examine it, rather than using the "pick up" option. I wonder how hard it would be for Jeff to add that back in. [ Wednesday, October 03, 2007 10:19: Message edited by: Ming ] Posts: 102 | Registered: Monday, September 3 2007 07:00 |
|
Shaper
Member # 6292
|
written Wednesday, October 3 2007 11:32
Profile
Apparently you are not wholly familiar with the perverse sense of humor that our beloved game creator thoroughly enjoys sharing with (inflicting upon) us, the game player. -S- -------------------- A4 Items • A4 Singleton • G4 Items • G4 Forging • G4 Infiltrator • NR Items • The Lonely Celt Posts: 2009 | Registered: Monday, September 12 2005 07:00 |
|
Law Bringer
Member # 6785
|
written Wednesday, October 3 2007 14:02
Profile
quote:No, Jeff does it deliberately to have a good laugh at his players. I just found a canister in A5 hidden behind a pillar 3 days ago that you can only find by moving the cursor over the hidden areas (you need the item inside to finish a quest easily). Get used to the idea of scanning the entire map this way whenever there is the slightest possibility of something being hidden by an object or wall. Posts: 4643 | Registered: Friday, February 10 2006 08:00 |
|
Apprentice
Member # 10811
|
written Wednesday, October 3 2007 15:54
Profile
Hmm. I think that I don't mind having to move the cursor around to find hidden doors or containers so much. It's really just a kind of equivalent to all of that head-banging required to find the secret doors in A1-3, isn't it? The impossibility of finding objects bothers me far more, as one can't even play "hunt the pixel" with the mouse in an attempt to find them. In fact, now that I think of it, the engine would be much improved for me if objects worked like doors and containers -- if they became highlit when you ran the mouse over them. That would solve much of my frustration with the engine right there. As things stand, though, the only brute force method of finding objects I can think of would be to put your lead guy in each square, and then repeatedly press "g." That's too much bother, especially since (as far as I can tell) there's no easy way to close the inventory window once it has opened. You have to use the mouse each time, which is very slow and inconvenient. Really, I think that my annoyance with the engine would be reduced a great deal if only it were possible to just hit 'enter' or something to close the inventory window, rather than having to direct the cursor to that check mark each and every time. Posts: 6 | Registered: Saturday, September 29 2007 07:00 |
|
Law Bringer
Member # 6785
|
written Wednesday, October 3 2007 16:07
Profile
ESC, the escape key, tends to work as a way to close most windows. The get command, "g" will usually work within two squares of any party member. It does get boring, but there is a limit to the amount of items you can get to sell for money. Posts: 4643 | Registered: Friday, February 10 2006 08:00 |
|
Councilor
Member # 6600
|
written Wednesday, October 3 2007 16:34
Profile
Homepage
Looking through all the graphics (in Data file for Windows, no idea for Mac) to identify and seperate the objects/items (obvious since each item has two graphics--one for when it is on the ground and the other when it is in your inventory) from the terrain and other non-pickupables might help. And hopefully after a bit more exploring, you'll recognize which things are items and which aren't. Dikiyoba. -------------------- Episode 4: Spiderweb Reloaded Posts: 4346 | Registered: Friday, December 23 2005 08:00 |
|
Lifecrafter
Member # 7252
|
written Thursday, October 4 2007 00:36
Profile
Whoa..new graphics for A5? Nice..I hope he makes custom graphics for some of the equips that are worth mentioning..Demonslayer and co. I'm tired of seeing the EC as a lump of green metal..it'll be better if it was a spiky, better looking, lump of green metal.. -------------------- Humans fight to enter insanity. You ain't evil until you hear this! Posts: 732 | Registered: Saturday, June 24 2006 07:00 |
|
Apprentice
Member # 10811
|
written Thursday, October 4 2007 12:56
Profile
Randomizer, I could have sworn that I tried ESC, and that it did something completely different (sent me to the main menu, perhaps?), but when I tried it again just now, it worked! Boy, do I feel foolish now. Thank you very much! Dikiyoba, thanks for the tip. I'm sure I will get used to it in time. As I hope you can tell, I really do want to find this game more fun than frustrating, since I've enjoyed the others in the series so very much. There's definitely good will for the franchise built up in my mind, which is the reason I'm willing to put in the effort. Had it been the first I'd tried, I suspect I would have written it off as "not for me" early on, but I'm now sufficiently invested in (addicted to?) the world that I really do want to play this game. I'm glad to hear there will be more character graphics introduced in the next one, especially since I favor all-nephil parties. Right now I basically have a party of clones in different colored loin-cloths wandering through the caves (the other nephil sprite I find too dark to be easily distinguishable from the background, so I'm left with only one option). It works, sure, but it's a little unsatisfying on the gut emotional level. Posts: 6 | Registered: Saturday, September 29 2007 07:00 |
